A friend tells me that Fox News reported heavily today on the National Popular Vote effort to abolish the Electoral College. This got me thinking about NPV’s potential effects on and interaction with multiparty competition. I suspect it would make the U.S. House more open to multiparty politics, but this would not be ground-shaking because the party system has been moving in that direction anyway.
My observations build on a 2020 blog post by Matthew Shugart. Its premise is that we can make good predictions about the number of parties in a place from the basic structure of its electoral system. The post makes three key points:
- The U.S. House already has less multiparty competition than we should expect based on the number of seats in it. (We also made this point in a 2023 essay on proportional representation.)
- Voting behavior in presidential elections already resembles that of a country with a nationwide plurality vote.
- The House is making the Senate party system more competitive than the Senate’s design features alone predict.
In sum: the Electoral College constrains the House, the House affects the Senate, and voters are behaving to some extent as though the Electoral College isn’t a factor.
A few developments since the post make me less likely to be surprised if NPV becomes law.
First, I’d argue we already have an informally institutionalized version of multiparty democracy. Groups like the Working Families Party and Vermont Progressive Party have been doing unusually well by winning Democratic ballot lines and/or securing or providing cross-endorsements. Some of this organizing is spilling over into races for national-level office. Then the trend has been for these groups to act (so far) as good coalition partners. One can argue about whether these entities are parties or party factions. The presence of that debate itself would support the point.
Second, there is the question of party attachment. The share of Americans refusing party identification has been climbing for some time. We will see soon enough what these numbers look like for 2026. One big story out of that election has been potentially further dealignment, manifest in voting behavior.
So, I would not be stunned if NPV became law. The coalition to adopt something like it may be closer to being in place than at any other point in my political memory. The demand for such a policy also may be present.
At the same time, these are observations, not predictions. Electoral reform is hard. There is also the question of whether the 50 state parties would act as such in passing the proposal. Has nationalization fully done in the party system’s federalism? It is hard to say.
My goal is to observe, not cheerlead. There are legal questions about NPV. I am not an expert on those, and this post sets them aside. Finally, it seems like a national popular vote would work best with runoffs. Cynthia McClintock’s book on Latin American party systems is worth reading on this point. She argues that runoffs have been stabilizing devices.