Example STV ballots

What did ballots look like in American single transferable vote elections? I can’t find examples, so I am licensing these photos for public use. The ballots are from Worcester, Massachusetts, which held six PR elections, 1949-59. Please tell me if you know of PR ballots from other cities.

Below is a demonstration ballot from the 1955 election. Note how it gives the residential address of each candidate. It also says which candidates are incumbents.

1955 sample STV ballot, Worcester (MA).

Below is the outer part of an official ballot from the 1959 election. It was folded lengthwise, and the voter marked their preferences on the inside.

1959 sample STV ballot (outside), Worcester (MA).

Below is the inner part of the same.

1959 sample STV ballot (inside), Worcester (MA).

Worcester voters repealed PR on November 8, 1960, after Democrats in the Citizens’ Plan E Association (CEA) lost interest. CEA was a joint endorsement scheme of the regular Republican Party and “reform” Democrats who supported PR in 1947.

It is interesting that the local AFL-CIO announced opposition to PR in December 1959. Massachusetts’ unions merged in 1958, and labor supported PR before then. Note that the CIO-affiliated Steelworkers ended PR in Cincinnati in 1957.

Creative Commons License
Each image is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

4 Comments

  • Howie Fain says:

    Is it surprising that street address and candidate for reelection appear on the ballot? In Massachusetts, both appear on all state and local ballots, except for US president.

    And perhaps it’s the street addresses that influenced the 1959 City Council election in Worcester. Two candidates shown on the ballot, incumbent Mike Favulli and Peter Tomaiolo, competed for the “East Side Italian-American seat” on the council; one or the other won that seat in 5 out of the 6 PR council elections.

    Favulli had won in 1957, but sometime over the next two years had moved to the West Side (Newton Avenue North!!). Tomaiolo, still an East-sider, was able to take the seat.

    Historical note: East side voters went strong for repeal in 1960, and promptly lost representation in the 9x at-large system that replaced it.

    • Jack says:

      Howie, thanks for this great context! Where are you getting the info? Local lore?

      Strictly with respect to the ballots, no, I’m not surprised about the addresses. Someone on Facebook recently posted a current MA absentee, and it looked eerily like these. But this is why I would love to see more ballots from the PR cases. What were they like in Ohio? How about Yonkers? New York City had partisan ballots, but they were organized by name, and party endorsements appeared under each candidate. I’d love to see one!

      • Howie Fain says:

        Jack, not lore; rather an early 1990s document of less-than-stellar academic rigor, entitled “District and Ethnic Loyalties under Proportional Representation in Worcester, 1949-1959.” A blend of amateur anysis of the PR results, last-name inferences, some knowledge of the city, the ward map from Binstock, and a conversation or two with descendants of participants. Check your email, Sept 10 2015. I actually think the amateur analysis is not only somewhat credible and relevant, it could lay the foundation for a more rigorous work, with some important lessons about distributing, identity voting blocs, etc. Let me know…

        • Jack says:

          Thanks. Favulli was a CEA Democrat 1956-9 (resulting from the 1955 and 1957 elections). He was a regular Democrat in 1954-5. I have neither Tomaiolo nor Favulli in the council of 1952-3. Tomaiolo served as regular Democrat in the first and last PR councils (1950-1, 1960-1). He’d been an Alderman in the pre-PR system. Let’s talk further.

          A general trend was the movement of regular Democrats into the CEA. Favulli begins this in the 1955 election. O’Brien continues it with the 1957 election. Archival records at WHM suggest a flood of regular Democrats into CEA in early 1955.

          Izzy Katz was CEA Democrat in 1952-3 and 1954-5. He loses in November 1955. He comes back as a regular Democrat in the elections of 1957 and 1959.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *